Category: Mediawatch

Categories
Mediawatch

What do Trump and Peppi Azzopardi have in common? (Nikkonfermaw li Norfolk Tezisti)

In another life – pre-Trump, pre-Covid, pre-two daughters – in the early days of J’accuse this blog, I had posted a little piece called “Nikkonfermaw li Norfolk Tezisti”. Snowed in, in my comfy flat in Merl I had chanced upon an episode of Xarabank that for that day had turned into a Maltese version of Would I lie to You? Now this was no David Mitchell or Lee Mack but a bunch of people unkown to me being compered by the dinosaur of Maltese TV at the time – Peppi Azzopardi.

This was 2008, and one of the storytellers on the show mentioned Norfolk en passant and this prompted good old Peppi to ask one of his assitants to…. confirm that Norfolk exists. Which they did. And they ended the show with the cringeworthy statement “Nikkonfermaw li Norfolk Tezisti” (we confirm that Norfolk exists). Any East Anglians watching the show that day must have felt relieved.

Fast forward to the day the Orange Clown residing in the White House announced his tarriffs on the world with much pomp and little circumstance. Within the absurdity of the measures that shoot the global economy back a century and a half lay a lovely easter egg waiting for exploitation by critics and comedians alike. For the Carrot Faced Buffoon had actually slapped tarriffs on uninhabited or sparsely inhabited places such as the Heard and MacDonald Islands and… wait for it… Norfolk Island.

While economists and analysts the world over were busy picking up the pieces of their jaws that had collectively clattered to the ground during the shit show that was the announcement of tarriffs, some others were trying to decipher the reason Putin’s Puppet would choose to punish islands whose main inhabitants are penguins.

Well it turns out that the reason behind this is an administrative error of sorts. A very lax person or persons somewhere in the US administration who was responsible for collecting trade data seems to have mislabelled certain transactions involving places such as Norfolk, VA (Virginia) – attributing them instead to an island 1,500 km east of Australia in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. You see. It’s not that Norfolk does not exist. In this case, it’s simply the wrong Norfolk.

That, ladies and gentlemen, says it all. In 2008, I thought that if a TV talk show host needs to ask his crew to confirm that Norfolk really exists and was not a figment of the imagination of a participant then we had hit the bottom. I was wrong. In 2025 the Leader of the Free World (not sure this still applies) created a global tarriff list based on data provided by minions who couldn’t tell their Pacific Islands from US states.

That’s all (Nor)folks! (sorry)

According to an analysis of US import data and shipping records, multiple shipments of goods were classified as having originated from Norfolk Island or Heard and McDonald islands when neither the company address, nor the port of departure for the shipment, nor the destination port were located in those territories. In some cases involving Norfolk Island, which is 1,600km north-east of Sydney and has a population of 2,188, the confusion appears to have resulted from the fact that the company’s address or port of departure is Norfolk, UK, or the destination is Norfolk, Virginia in the US, or a company’s registered address in New Hampshire (NH) has been listed instead as Norfolk Island (NI).

(the Guardian)

Categories
Mediawatch

The seven year wait

Joseph Muscat’s government had been in power for 1682 days on the day Daphne Caruana Galizia was assassinated. That’s 4 years, 7 months and 7 days.

On the last of those 4 years, 7 months and 7 days Daphne Caruana Galizia would write those fatal words that are now part of the history of this nation. “The crooks are everywhere you look now. The situation is desperate.”

It took just 1682 days, probably even less, for the crooks to spread themselves “everywhere you look”. It took just nigh 5 years under the watch of Joseph Muscat’s government for the situation to become desperate.

The 16th October 2017 was a dark day in Malta’s history. It was the day a journalist was brutally silenced for doing her work. Daphne Caruana Galizia was shedding light on an intricate web of corruption within the political elite. That corruption, that democratic backsliding, did not stop on the 16th October. That day only served to ignite a flame and a quest for justice – as that banner crafted by Daphne’s father loudly proclaims in the fields of Bidnija.

Seven years have gone by since that fateful day. Seven years without Daphne. Seven years in which the battle for the truth has not abated. Yet seven years in which the backsliding, the corruption, the lack of meritocracy also seem to hold strong.

Time. It still surprises me. That figure of 4 years 7 months and one week is impressive when you think of it. It is a brief amount of time in which a huge number of corrupt decisions and appointments were made. the seeds of scandals must have been sown early on during the Muscat legislature but they grew fast enough to fester and draw the attention of Malta’s sharpest investigative journalist.

4 years, 7 months and one week were enough to turn the Running Commentary into an encyclopedic chronicle of the realm of crooked dealings. Seven years after the attempt to silence the chronicler’s message we still do not realise the enormity of Muscat’s government’s achievements. Hospitals, power stations, health agreements, public contracts, the public service itself – all of these twisted to the service of a self-serving, self-entitled cadre of trough hogging pigs.

In the course of one legislature the systemic breakdown of a nation was plotted and put into action. Daphne Caruana Galizia’s attention to detail was too uncomfortable for the record breaking concocters of corruption. They had managed to neutralise the constitutional checks and balances but Caruana Galizia was too loud, too distracting, too dangerously close to the truth to be allowed the luxury of working.

They tried to cripple her through her resources. They tried to bully her into submission. They tried sent little men to stalk her and follow her every move. When that did not work they moved in for the kill.

Then it happened. 4 years, 7 months and one week after Joseph Muscat was elected to power a bomb went off in Bidnija that would send shock waves to the system.

Seven years later we take stock of the battle for justice for Daphne. It is a battle for transparency that goes beyond the freedom of expression and safety of journalists. Like it or not, it has become a battle for the Republic and whatever values remain.

The long, hard struggle remains essentially a frustrating effort. The damage wrought on the constitutional balances in the first five years of Labour in power runs deep. Initiatives at national and international level following the assassination are still not bearing the desired fruits and resistance to proper change remains palpable.

As the conversation on Malta’s political future continues, it is clear that the spirit of Daphne Caruana Galizia’s work lives on in those who continue to seek truth and justice. The path ahead is one of reflection, reform, and resilience, as we grapple with our past to shape a more just and open society.

Categories
Mediawatch

Human Capital

“Abbiamo alzato la posta, ci siamo giocati tutto, anche il futuro dei nostri figli. E adesso finalmente ci godiamo quello che ci spetta.”

from “Il Capitale Umano”, Paolo Virzi

A migrant worker falls from the height of two storeys while working on a construction site. Someone, probably the migrant worker’s employer, puts him in the car with a promise to take him to hospital. Instead of taking him to hospital he dumps the injured worker on the side of the road and leaves him there unassisted and in pain. It takes some good willing passers by to stop and assist the desperate and injured man and call an ambulance.

There are scarcely any words that can describe this horrible act that took place in Malta today, in September 2021. It exposes the full horror of the exploitation of migrant workers on the island and particularly the cold-blooded calculations of the construction industry when dealing with human lives. The 32 year old Ghanaian feared prison almost more than the physical pain that he was surely enduring. He was aware of his precarious situation in which he found himself – that same precarious situation was at the root of the cold calculation of his employer who opted to dump him on the road side.

The irony in the news.

The construction sector’s rabid hunger for development – crystallised in Joseph Portelli’s prophetic “hundred more years” words during an interview – is completely insensitive to the human damage that it causes.

That damage is quantifiable first of all in the loss of quality of life that the irrational and corrupt spread of construction is causing to the nation as a whole. Malta, Gozo and Comino are gradually being suffocated under a blanket of unbridled, irrational and destructive development. The warnings had been made only a week ago – to the point that the Prime Minister felt it necessary to “reassure” the construction sector after even one of his own had pointed an accusatory finger in their direction.

Quality of life is at dangerous low levels on the island of milk and honey. There is little respite from the continuous onslaught that is aided and abetted by weak or powerless institutions and a by the network of compromised politicians.

The damage is quantifiable even further in the loss of lives by people who become collateral damage of the unregulated and irresponsible frenzy that is around us. The fear of being buried alive is a real possibility that is only a minor blip on the dark register of constructor’s accounts. Death becomes a tiny cost to bear in the race to construct the new Babylon.

Health and safety standards, Employment standards, Building Regulations. They are all dependent on the will to enforce. Such a will is absent and there can be little hope for a nation gearing up for an election where politicians are eager to capitalise on the investments made by their construction lobby masters (“I meet them daily to facilitate my plans”).

Employment conditions for non-EU workers are atrociously balanced in favour of the Employing market. Short-term resident permits and contracts leave employees at the mercy of their employers who are aided by laws drafted in their favour. The government’s role in this situation is not to be understimated.

The same government that is dishing out millions of Euros on the eve of an election that were received on the basis of a residency scheme for the rich shows us how little it values human capital elsewhere. Responsibility lies squarely with our politicians in this respect.

“Avete scommesso sulla rovina di questo paese. E avete vinto.”

from Il Capitale Umano, Paolo Virzi

Categories
Mediawatch

The EU Digital COVID Certificate and Malta’s Latest Measures

Malta’s latest COVID measures have still not been made into law. Although the measures announced over the weekend are meant to come into effect tomorrow, the Legal Notice that should make them law has not been published yet. The latest measures have proven to be controversial due to the stringent conditions imposed in what seems to be a panic reaction following a surge in COVID cases. Without entering into the controversy of what is the reason behind this surge it is interesting to see where Malta’s proposed measures stand in the light of Malta’s EU obligations.

We are all familiar by now with the main thrust of the new measures: that only fully vaccinated persons can travel to Malta. As the weekend unfolded we also heard of possible exceptions being introduced, notably for Maltese caught abroad by the new measures who will be allowed to use a PCR test on their return without being quarantined.

In an interesting development yesterday, the EU Commission voiced its doubts on whether the Maltese measures were compatible with EU legislation – particularly since they risk being discriminatory. In fact the rules have to be viewed in the light of the EU Digital Covid Certificate Regulation of the 14th June 2021 that creates a framework for the issuance, verification and acceptance of interoperable COVID-19 vaccination, test and recvovery certificates in order ot facilitate free movement during the COVID-19 pandemic.

It is clear that the main intention behind this regulation is to continue to guarantee the fundamental right to move and reside freely within the territory of the Member States. The creation of what is described as an “interoperable” certificate is intended to uniformise the certification aspect that can be used whenever Member States are limiting the right to movement on grounds of public health. The emphasis is on having a universally accepted certification that any MS can use as a criteria for limiting free movement under specific conditions.

In fact, the 6th preamble of the Regulation stipulates:

“(…)Any restrictions to the free movement of persons within the Union that are put in place to limit the spread of SARS-CoV-2 should be based on specific and limited public interest grounds, namely the safeguarding of public health as emphasised by Recommendation (EU) 2020/1475. It is necessary for such limitations to be applied in accordance with the general principles of Union law, in particular proportionality and non-discrimination. Any measures taken should therefore be strictly limited in scope and time, in line with the efforts to restore free movement within the Union, and should not extend beyond what is strictly necessary to safeguard public health.”

Additionally, the 36th consideration in the preamble specifies (my emphasis):

It is necessary to prevent direct or indirect discrimination against persons who are not vaccinated, for example because of medical reasons, because they are not part of the target group for which the COVID -19 vaccine is currently administered or allowed, such as children, or because they have not yet had the opportunity or chose not to be vaccinated. Therefore, possession of a vaccination certificate, or the possession of a vaccination certificate indicating a COVID-19 vaccine, should not be a pre-condition for the exercise of the right to free movement or for the use of cross-border passenger transport services such as airlines, trains, coaches or ferries or any other means of transport. In addition, this Regulation cannot be interpreted as establishing a right or obligation to be vaccinated.

So while the Regulation is intended to provide a universally accepted certificate of verification that might be used by Member States as a requirement for entry, it is also clear that this requirement can never be used to deprive citizens of their right of movement.

Article 3 (6) of the Regulation is very clear in this regard:

6.   Possession of the certificates referred to in paragraph 1 shall not be a precondition for exercising the right to free movement.

Article 11 on the other hand considers the possibility of restrictions to free movement in extraordinary circumstances such as a rapid worsening of the epidemiological situation. While this article does not exactly contemplate the possibility of restricting movement only to COVID-19 Vaccination Certificate holders (as the Maltese measures would), it does allow Member States to require certificate holders (which includes Vaccinated, Recovered and PCR test certificate holders and not only Vaccinated Certificate holders) to undergo quarantine, self-isolation or further testing.

In such cases the Member State is bound to inform the Commission the reasons for such restrictions, the scope of such restrictions and the date and duration of such restrictions.

In the light of the above, and considering that we are not yet fully informed of the exact details of what the Maltese measures will entail other than what has been described generally, it would seem that the new measures could be in violation of Malta’s obligations under the Regulation.

Having said that, I stress that this opinion is merely an interpretation of mine. In order to have a clear answer black on white what would need to happen is a challenge of the Legal Notice introducing the measures before the courts and, in case the national courts have a doubt as to the interpretation of the regulation, a reference to the Court of Justice in Luxembourg that would give the ultimate binding interpretation.

The fact that the measures concern public health might be a mitigating factor on the one hand. On the other hand, the Regulation does seem to contemplate the possibility of exceptional measures and outlines the conditions for their application. In that case it might not be enough for Malta to invoke Public Health issues where the exceptions that the national measures are introducing go beyond what is contemplated in the Regulation and are both disproportionate and discriminatory.

I trust that once the Legal Notice is published we will be able to make a clearer analysis of the situation.

Categories
Mediawatch

Good Night & Good Luck 2021

This year has been a quiet year on this blog. Most of my writing has taken place elsewhere, mostly on the j’accuse column over at the Shift News. It’s not just COVID19 that is to blame for the year with least posts on www.akkuza.com but also the wonderful arrival of Maddalena Victoria into our lives that required a slight readjustment of routines in the Zammit-Sartori household.

Politically speaking 2020 has been a weird year that unfolded under the sign of this cataclysmic change of social habits. Many questions were asked of those who purport to govern our nations leading to a sudden realisation as to why the people elect wardens of the state. What I mean is that once the ‘business as usual’ of corrupt and economy-driven politics of the 21st century was eclipsed by an urgent need to manage the general common wealth for all citizens, our politicians were found lacking.

As we ask questions of our political class we also realise the widening of a dangerous knowledge gap in our society. A society that has been supposedly empowered with new tools for the discovery and understanding of knowledge has strangely retreated to a mass mentality that seems to precede the advent of science and reason.

The program of government struggled to balance the new priorities and challenges of the modern age. Health and the environment were suddenly catapulted to the forefront of our concerns with varying degrees of acceptance. Change with a big C was on its way, provoked by the unavoidable adaptation to new work and life conditions. Sadly, although the whole of the human race was under threat, the walls and differences created by centuries of history proved to be resistant and still lead to a disparate, egoistic replies to common problems.

Closer to home, the status quo has barely shifted. The Gattopardian adage still applies strongly as a wave of artificial change and reform is used to mask the fact that at the core we remain the same. One of the fathers of Malta’s constitution passed away this month while we are very far from taking up the much needed drastic reform from the roots that might save the nation from the backsliding that it has witnessed in the past decade.

There is as little faith in our wardens of the state as there is hope for change. Yet we must struggle on calling out the system for what it is. It is our duty as citizens and or duty towards our sons and daughters.

As the sun sets for one last time in 2020 I would like to thank all those who have read and followed J’accuse throughout the year. 2021 will be a tough year of recovery and adaptation, I look forward to sharing these experiences with readers and followers of J’accuse… the truth, if I lie.

One last thing. My thoughts go out to Darrin Zammit Lupi and his daughter Becs. Over this holiday period I have clung hopefully to every Facebook entry that Darrin posts. I can only pray and hope that Darren and his family find the courage to get through this ordeal and that the wonderful Becky gets back to dancing, creating and enjoying life as soon as possible.

Categories
Mediawatch Politics Rule of Law

Frozen too late

On this night when the news broke of the freezing of assets of Keith Schembri, Brian Tonna and others we need to take a step back and realise that the information that led to this action has been in the public domain for at least three years.

On April 24th 2017, Daphne Caruana Galizia published a post entitled “BREAKING/Prime Minister’s chief of staff took kickbacks from Brian Tonna on sale of Maltese citizenship”. In that post, as the title describes, she detailed fact upon fact of how Keith Schembri had received kickbacks from Brian Tonna on the sale of citizenship.

The ball, you could say, was in the AG’s court. Action could and should have been taken. Instead we all know what would happen. Nothing. No prosecutions. No investigations. Keith Schembri would remain a key figure in disgraced PM Muscat’s kitchen cabinet and Brian Tonna’s Nexia would feature in many a government contract or consultancy until yesterday.

And Daphne Caruana Galizia would be murdered.

Reading this comment by Daphne has a spine-chilling effect. It thunders from beyond the grave and reverberates in our heads. There you have it. She knew that publishing these facts would not be enough. She knew that the police would do nothing with this evidence.

“It’s the Prime Minister’s chief of staff, so they’re not going to touch him.” Daphne was one of the select few who were aware at the time of the system of impunity that was already in place. Institutions had by then already been bent into submission. The saga was only about to begin.

Action by the police at the time might have prevented the disastrous vortex that was to follow.

Daphne Caruana Galizia began to die that night. She did not have to, but the nation was too blind to realize the possible consequences of this kind of revelation. Blinded by partisan bickering and by government propaganda the people would only serve as a fertile ground for institutional breakdown.

And murder.

This is what justice for Daphne is also about. We are a long way from that yet.

ADDENDUM:
This is how the lying lowlife scum reacted at the time. Thanks to @bugdavem on Twitter for the reminder.